The Internet helped a man find his missing dog. But the family who rescued him didn't want to give him up.
Finding good, reliable dog sitting is difficult under normal circumstances. Who can you really trust to take care of your dog? Will they be safe? Will they be scared while you're gone? When you're a soldier in the US military deployed for months at a time, dog-care can turn into an actual nightmare very quickly.
No one knows this better than Paulo Silva, a US Navy soldier who was recently deployed on an aircraft carrier in the Middle East for eight months. While he was away, Silva trusted a relative to watch his five-year-old Golden Retriever and certified bestie, Archie.
When Silva returned home, excited to reunite with his best friend, he was shocked to find the dog gone.
Archie, a 5-year-old golden retriever, became the unwitting subject of a social media custody battle. Photo by Mitchell Luo on Unsplash
“A family member that was well-trusted felt they had no choice but to give away my dog,” Silva told the Asbury Park Press. “At no point was I told about it (before returning home) and I had asked time and time again about him." The relative told Silva that Archie was having trouble settling in, but the decision still came as a massive shock. Worse, Silva's relative couldn't or wouldn't provide him the contact information of the family he'd given Archie to. In interviews, Silva hasn't said much about the reasoning behind these cruel decisions. All he knew was he was scared and left scrambling.
Silva posted a desperate plea to Facebook for anyone with information to contact him. Then social media did what it always seems to do in stories like this one: it delivered.
The post went mega-viral, being shared all across different social and professional networks in the area, and before too long, Silva received tips about where he could find his dog. Not too long after that, Silva and Archie were joyously reunited.
What a perfect happy ending for this feel-good social media story, right? Well, not quite.
It's easy to root for the storybook ending, but there's another family at the other end of the story. For them, it's anything but a fairy tale.
When the tipster first reached out to Silva with Archie's whereabouts, there was one problem: the people who had taken Archie in didn't want to give him up and wouldn't respond to messages.
He had been adopted, apparently freely, by a young woman and her boyfriend when Silva's relative decided to find Archie a new home. In their minds, Archie belonged to them, fair and square, and after months of love and snuggles and care, they had bonded deeply with him. They were sorry for the situation Silva found himself in, but they weren't going to simply "roll over."
Silva then wrote an open letter to Archie's new family, pleading his case.
"This dog isn’t just a pet to me. He is my heart, my companion, and a piece of my soul that helped carry me through some of the hardest times in my life. We’ve been through everything together—before my deployment, during training, and through the toughest emotional battles. That kind of bond is irreplaceable," he wrote.
"I love this dog more than words can express—more than life itself. First, I want to say that I appreciate that you’ve cared for my dog. I have no doubt that you’re good people and that you’ve offered a safe and loving home. But I need you to know that this wasn’t supposed to happen. I was never asked, never informed, and never had the chance to speak up or say goodbye. I left for duty trusting that my dog would be waiting for me when I came home. I’m reaching out publicly not out of anger, but out of heartbreak. I am respectfully asking you to please consider returning my dog to me. I know this isn’t an easy request, and I understand that emotions may be involved on both sides—but I am pleading with you, not just as a veteran, but as someone who lost something deeply precious to them without any choice or voice in the matter."
According to the Asbury Press, Silva was considering legal action if the couple didn't return Archie.
Eventually, the woman and her boyfriend who had adopted Archie decided to return him to Silva. They were heartbroken about the decision.
Even worse, beyond just losing the dog they loved, Jamie Goldstein and her boyfriend were cast as villains in the now-viral story. They began receiving hate messages and public pressure to turn over the dog. While some people threw their support behind the couple's right to keep Archie, many more sent nasty messages and threats.
After they decided to send Archie back to his original home, Goldstein shared an emotional letter of her own on social media.
"He is the sweetest boy and everyone who has met him can attest to it. I love this dog with all my heart," she wrote. "Archie was never stolen, he was given to my boyfriend, we just loved him as our own. ... I can only imagine how Paulo felt when he came back from serving our country & didnt know where sweet Archie was. This feels like a mourning. I miss you so much already, I hope you are safe & getting all the love you deserve, baby Archie. We miss you so much."
Although the couple ultimately did the right thing, it's hard not to feel deeply for them and their loss. Their quick love for Archie was so apparent, and it's unfair that things unfolded the way they did.
As for Silva, he's incredibly grateful for the family that took Archie in and loved him for those many months.
"I do not see them as villains and you shouldn’t either," he wrote in another post. "I know their hearts were in the right place. Thank you both for loving Archie as your own. I will always be grateful for that. I will never stop showing you guys my love and support."
He even offered to arrange an "open door policy" so the couple could visit Archie any time they wanted.
While the story is full of debate and heartbreak, there is one clear winner: Archie. What a lucky pup to be so loved by two different families. If anything, the story speaks volumes about how quickly and powerfully pets can find a place in our hearts. It also ends with mutual kindness, both in the couple returning Archie and Silva handling the conflict with grace. It may not be your typical feel-good social media reunion, but it's got plenty of silver lining.
- Golden Retriever with remarkable healing skills earns the total trust of a terrified kitten ›
- Golden Retriever's unbridled excitement over new dog bed is too sweet not to watch ›
- Lovable Golden Retriever follows maps trekker and photobombs over 1,000 locations ›
- Family brings home the wrong dog from daycare until their cats saved the day ›
Older man sitting at the computer. 
Older people taking an aerobics class.
An elderly man laughs.
Lessons in "purity' unfortunately start very young for many girls. Photo by 
You don't "lose" anything when you have sex for the first time.
Women are judged for losing their virginity; men are mocked for failing to do so.
First dates are intimidating, especially as we get older.
Photo by 
Yes, even us elder-millennials can meet someone new and fall in love at any point in life.
Photo by 
Tinder is the top dating app in the United States.
Photo by 
A hunting/fishing filter on Tinder: Who says no?
Photo by 
Some users want the Tinder algorithm to weed out people with old or heavily filtered photosUnsplash
Make space for other people around you.
Be mindful of making noise in public spaces.
Give genuine compliments often.
Hold the door for everyone.
Don't give in to the road rage.
Show patience to others.
Say Thank You more often.
Leave places a little cleaner than you found them.
Parenting in 2025 is a lot different than in the 1980s.
Photo by 
