Video of school kids in China bouncing balls in unison is like a cultural Rorschach test
It's been nearly 100 years since Hermann Rorschach introduced the well-known inkblot test used by psychologists to analyze personality characteristics and emotional processing. Where one person sees a bat, another may see a butterfly. One person might find an inkblot shape soothing while another finds it unnerving.
Whether the test truly tells psychologists anything definitive, there's no doubt that our perceptions are colored by our thoughts, emotions, and experiences. And that's quite clear in people's reactions to this video from a school in China.
The video, shared by ShanghaiPanda on Twitter, shows a large circle of children bouncing dozens of balls in unison and moving around the circle in a rhythmic pattern. "China's kindergarten game: Cooperation," the post reads.
China's kindergarten game: Cooperation. https://t.co/2vxAsEetHm— ShanghaiPanda (@ShanghaiPanda) 1598192468.0
Responses to the post reveal a wide range of perceptions of the purpose and value of the activity. As a former teacher, I see kids learning and practicing excellent hand-eye coordination and spatial awareness. I also see them working together, cooperating to keep the balls moving in unison. To me, it's a really cool example of using the whole body to perform a task and focusing one's attention on what's in front of them while preparing for what's to come. It also builds trust, as you have to trust that your neighbor is going to perform their task of bouncing the ball at the right time, and your other neighbor has to trust that you will do the same. (A far better lesson than, say, the cut-through terror and individual dominance most of us remember from playing dodgeball in school.)
From my perspective, this is a valuable group activity for young kids that teaches multiple skills at the same time.
But for others, it's a creepy example of group-think indoctrination, molding kids to accept uniformity and train them into obedience.
@thinking_panda Doesn't look like a game to me. Seems more like training in automatism and obedience. Just the kin… https://t.co/LnaRghwsDI— Liberal Furibundo (@Liberal Furibundo) 1598228256.0
If the first thing you think of when you think of Chinese culture is communist indoctrination, then I can see why this video would elicit that response. But that doesn't make it correct or okay.
Thankfully, most of those responses were met with rebuttals that showed the hypocrisy and xenophobia inherent in them.
@philharmagic @topeLiberal @thinking_panda And the pledge blasted to us every single morning from Elementary till High School— Cándido Josué Rodríguez Zelaya (@Cándido Josué Rodríguez Zelaya) 1598241317.0
Considering how we have kids recite the pledge of allegiance to the U.S. flag every morning in unison, the "indoctrination" argument falls a bit flat.
@YCNHE @thinking_panda Comparing a class of young children playing together to soldiers... I dont wanma say you did… https://t.co/7GdbTCbFXY— jumpenny (@jumpenny) 1598283549.0
@SvePan1108 @thinking_panda That’s literally not the definition of cooperation. Cooperation just means working toge… https://t.co/EERVQEVSDF— KISS YOUR HOMIES ON THE LIPS (@KISS YOUR HOMIES ON THE LIPS) 1598272704.0
Not to mention, nearly anything can be twisted into something dark or sinister simply by describing it that way, as evidenced by this description of "musical chairs."
@AncapEgor @thinking_panda @armesillaconde Musical chairs: how to make humans ok with monopolies and one person tak… https://t.co/FEpmJn0nSj— Communist Sailor Moon ☭ 🇬🇹🚩 (@Communist Sailor Moon ☭ 🇬🇹🚩) 1598277276.0
The video also ignited some interesting conversations about competition vs. coordination.
Ultimately, the idea that working together in unison to build skills and create a cool effect is somehow "communist indoctrination" is purely a product of people's perceptions about China and its people. After all, our marching bands and cheer squads do the same thing.
@mediocrebitch47 @thinking_panda Teaching our kids that working together as a team for a common goal used to be a g… https://t.co/MIHN0SJKw4— ALargeJD&Full-FatCokePlease 🙃 (@ALargeJD&Full-FatCokePlease 🙃) 1598284722.0
If our first impression or reaction to a video of kids doing something educational in another country is "that's creepy" or "ew, communism" we may want to check ourselves. Replace those kids faces with ones who look American to you and be honest about what your reaction would be to see it. Our prejudices can color our perceptions, and it's important for all of us to acknowledge and challenge our own thoughts.
Especially when we're looking at children bouncing balls, for goodness sake.
- A girl said books made her wish she wasn't Chinese. So her dad ... ›
- The Ancient Chinese Secret To Living A More Fulfilling Life - Upworthy ›
- When I Saw This List Of Things Made In China, I Didn't Expect To Be ... ›