An email sent out by the LPGA has created quite the storm online.
This is a woman playing golf.
Image via iStock.
This is a man playing golf.
Image via iStock.
It sure seems like they're playing the same sport, huh? You'd think the expectations surrounding their attire would reflect that, but a new controversial email sent out by the Ladies Professional Golf Association (LPGA) has thrown that into question.
And people definitely have some thoughts.
Earlier this month, the LPGA notified its players about updates in the organization's dress code.
The email, sent by LPGA player president Vicki Goetze-Ackerman, listed a number of policies regarding players' clothing and asked members to abide by the guidelines beginning July 17, 2017.
Here's how the email read, as Golf Digest pointed out:
- Racerback with a mock or regular collar are allowed (no collar = no racerback)
- Plunging necklines are NOT allowed.
- Leggings, unless under a skort or shorts, are NOT allowed
- Length of skirt, skort, and shorts MUST be long enough to not see your bottom area (even if covered by under shorts) at any time, standing or bent over.
- Appropriate attire should be worn to pro-am parties. You should be dressing yourself to present a professional image. Unless otherwise told "no," golf clothes are acceptable. Dressy jeans are allowed, but cut-offs or jeans with holes are NOT allowed.
- Workout gear and jeans (all colors) NOT allowed inside the ropes
- Joggers are NOT allowed
As you might expect, the LPGA's email sparked a wave of criticism online.
As Teen Vogue put it, the list "leaves you wondering, what is allowed?"
Policing what women wear on the golf course is taking a step backward (maybe even into a previous century), some argued.
@RobinMeade @AndyScholesCNN #lpga players teeing it up this morning for first round. https://t.co/PMxg9FhKYI— Old Country (@Old Country) 1500465552.0
"Plain and simple this is a mistake by the LPGA," one Twitter user wrote. "The athletic wear is fine and crosses no line.
But many people — most notably, several LPGA players themselves — don't see why people are making a fuss.
"There’s very minimal change to what our previous dress code is," golfer Christina Kim — who's currently competing in the LPGA tournament near Toledo, Ohio, this week — told The Detroit News. "I don’t know what people are making the hoopla about."
Fellow pro golfer Paige Spiranac tweeted that she doesn't think the dress code goes far enough.
@SophWalks @LPGA Untucked shirts, and clothes that don't fit (too tight or loose) should be added. Because I think… https://t.co/pI6tN47vtY— Paige Spiranac (@Paige Spiranac) 1500181719.0
Amid the backlash, it's worth comparing these rules to the dress code for men competing in the PGA.*
(*Why the women's association has an "L" in its name while the men's association apparently doesn't need to clarify gender is an article for a different day.)
According to the PGA's official website, its male "players shall present a neat appearance in both clothing and personal grooming. Clothing worn by players shall be consistent with currently accepted golf fashion."
And that's ... that.
The LPGA's (very) detailed email to its players reflects a bigger societal problem.
Double standards between men and women's athletic wear is nothing new.
In certain sports, standard attire requires girls and women wear much less than their male counterparts while competing. But in other sports, women are expected to cover up. We seem to police female athletes' bodies — in tennis arenas, swimming pools, volleyball courts, and more — with much more scrutiny than we do their male counterparts.
U.S. Olympic beach volleyball players Misty May-Treanor (left) and Sean Rosenthal (right). Photos by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images, Ryan Pierse/Getty Images.
The LPGA, however, maintains that its dress code is certainly not the latest example of any sexist industry double standard.
Amid the uproar, the LPGA released a statement, blasting media reports and claiming the criticism has been misguided.
The statement reads, as Yahoo News reported:
"Recent comments in the media about a 'new' LPGA dress code are much to do about nothing. We simply updated our existing policy with minor clarifications, which were directed by our members for our members. This is not a regression, but rather a clarification for members of the policy, with references relevant to today's fashion styles. There was not meant to be, nor will there be, a discernible difference to what players are currently wearing out on Tour."
Regardless of the LPGA's dress code, the fact the organization's email sparked such strong responses shows this is a discussion we must keep having.
After all, athletes of all genders should be seen as competitors — as athletes capable of dressing in the clothes that enable them to be great at their sport — not as aesthetic objects to patrol.
"Policing these women's bodies and clothes takes away from their professional accomplishments," Suzannah Weiss wrote for Teen Vogue. "And if the sport wants a positive image, body-shaming is not the way to get it."