Researchers studied the ways spending affects our happiness. The results are eye-opening.
It can be hard to resist a good sale.
Especially when they're so hard to avoid. The U.S., for example, has more mall space than any other country in the world. No matter which way you turn, bargains will tempt.
But don't be too quick to unholster your credit card because science may point you in a happier direction.
A 2015 psychological study out of Cornell University looked at different ways we spend our money and the "hedonic payoff" — the amount of pleasure or happiness we get — of those decisions.
"Given a world in which consumers have limited discretionary income (that is, the real world for nearly everyone), an important concern is howthey can get the most hedonic bang for their bucks. Although the relationship between money and happiness has been the subject of considerable debate ... few would deny that the financial choices people make can influence their well-being. That is, perhaps money can make us happier, provided we spend it on the right things."
The researchers introduce their work with a memorable movie quote that embodies their findings:
In the 1942 film "Casablanca," Humphrey Bogart's character sends off an old flame with this bittersweet certitude: "We'll always have Paris."
It turns out our phenomenal human ability to remember can play a big role when it comes to making consumer choices that keep our minds in a happy place.
In a way, we're all like kids growing bored with our toys.
The researchers found that experiences can bring us longer-lasting happiness than things can.
Once our basic needs are met, bills paid, and savings set aside, spending what we have left on new experiences (versus new stuff) can actually make us happier people.
That might mean traveling in another country, exploring a national park, jumping out of a plane, enjoying a dinner out, visiting a museum, or even just catching a movie. When you pay for an experience, what matters is that you leave with memories.
Why? Because as the saying goes, "We are the sum of our experiences."
Where we've been, what we've seen, and what we've done all help shape who we are. The same can't be said of the things we buy. The researchers say that's due to "hedonic adaptation," which, in short, means we get tired of stuff.
While our material things may endure, says the study, they inevitably lose their luster. In a way, we're all like kids growing bored with our toys:
"Once we get used to them they provide very little in terms of lasting happiness, causing us to want more and more, a phenomenon that has been dubbed the 'hedonic treadmill.'"
But memories of our experiences stay with us and evolve over time. And with enough time, we may even find it easier to see silver linings in our disappointing experiences than in our disappointing possessions:
"It is hard to romanticize a car or computer that breaks down frequently, or a shirt or sofa that is uncomfortable. Experiences, in contrast, live on only in the mind as mental representations that can be altered, reworked, and made more favorable."
Plus, sharing experiences gives opportunities to learn and relate, not compare ourselves to others, as is often the case with material possessions.
So as you plan for holidays and birthdays, or even if you just have some spare cash and want to...
...think about what's going to make you or your giftees happier in the long run: a lasting memory or an object that's destined for dullness?